Wednesday, September 15, 2010

"What's my story?"

I talked with D on the phone a couple of mornings ago, and it was a useful conversation.

She started by explaining just how crazy her life has been lately. Mostly this means that her job, which is always nuts, has been nuts. But she put a bit of a finer point on it by making it clear just how alone she has been feeling. Of course she no longer has her church job, having given that up years ago because she couldn't hold it and also be involved with me. But she is feeling lonelier at her regular job, too, because most of her friends quit last year over the ridiculous administration. D herself was tempted to quit, but tries to be careful and practical; as a woman in her late fifties, she doesn't imagine that she is going to be very employable anyway -- particularly if she walks out on a "perfectly good job" because she "can't get along with management." So she stayed. And she is surrounded by new people who mean well but don't know what they are doing. So she feels isolated.

This is why she has been getting so clingy and demanding about knowing exactly when she and I are going to see each other again; because she doesn't have anyone to talk to. (Well, of course she and I write each other long e-mails almost daily, but there is something to be said for physical presence. Also, we can't fuck over e-mail. I think I have mentioned that sex is a really big deal for D.) It's also why she was insisting recently that we plan out exactly how we are going to share expenses for future visits -- as a way of nailing down the details so that the trips themselves are more likely. When I more or less refused to be pinned down on this question, she called me "commitment-phobic." "Commitment-phobic?" Really? Isn't that what you say about a young man who doesn't want to have to marry his sweetheart, but also doesn't want to give her up? What exactly is "commitment-phobia" in this -- highly non-marital -- context?

Well, "commitment-phobia" may be the wrong word, but she has been experiencing a loss of faith in her job. She used to believe that her job really mattered, in a fundamental sense; and that belief helped her face the 18-hour days and the lunatic administration. Last year she finally decided, reluctantly, that it is just a job. That is freeing in a sense, because she no longer feels compelled to be perfect every single day. But it leaves her wondering what she is doing with her life. Where is the over-arching theme or value or narrative that makes sense of where she is in life? Or as she put it at one point, "What is my story these days?" Added to the loss of her church life and her friends, this deep uncertainty has made things very difficult for her.

As a result, she was pinning more and more of her meaning and self-definition on our relationship. When I backed out of answering direct questions like "What schedule can you commit to for seeing each other?" or "What financial arrangements can you commit to, in order to pay for these visits?" what she began to feel was something akin to, "My God, isn't there anything solid in my life that I can hold onto?" That's a scary thought when everything around you seems to be melting; and once I understood it, I tried to offer some comfort. It's just that trying to pin me down to everything but a ring and a bouquet was a really counter-productive way of articulating her fear. But I'm sure she hadn't thought it out all that clearly ahead of time.

I also told her that I see the potential for going through the same kind of thing myself in a couple of years: maybe not today, maybe not tomorrow, ... but maybe once Son 2 starts high school. So what would this mean? If Providence strips away from both of us all the external trappings that have defined who we are for years, ... how do we read that? Where do we go next?

I wish I knew.

Monday, September 13, 2010

Sister Failure

Some time ago I saw an article about Philip Schultz's recent book of poetry, Failure, and I knew I had to get it. Somehow the title was too evocative to miss.

I am kind of new to poetry. Some people live with poetry all their adult lives. Me, I found it strange -- modern poetry especially. Plus I had a girlfriend in college who found poetry very profound, and who was always urging me to read this or that piece ... words scattered haphazardly across the page, breaks in the damnedest places, verbs or punctuation missing. So I'd read it, and she would look at me expectantly, as if I were about to experience some shattering revelation that we could then discuss for the next three hours, and all I could say was "Huh?" It was never the right thing to say. So I shied away from the whole thing; and with only a very few exceptions -- most notably William Blake, whom I discovered in graduate school and whom I whole-heartedly love, yes, including all his bizarre prophetic visions -- I say, with only a very few exceptions I stayed away for decades.

I can't place what brought me around to be interested. Maybe it was my affair with D, who sends me books of poetry but doesn't act like she is giving me an exam. Maybe it was when I started trying to write poems for her -- far more structured than modern, as you have been able to see. Whatever brought it on, it has been comparatively recent. But I am enjoying it.

Anyway, I read this article about Schultz's book, and the title instantly spoke to me. I don't know why, exactly. When I told D about it, she got cross with me at first, telling me that I had no business "considering myself a failure" just because this or that hadn't worked out in my life the way I had planned.

Whoa, whoa, ... wait a minute. I never said it had anything to do with how things had turned out in my life. Nor did I say that I found anything sad or pitiful in the thought of failure. I know the word is often used as a form of condemnation or reproach, a disgrace, a cause for remorse. But I don't think it has to be any of those things; and more and more these days I feel that it isn't. Failure just means that you set out to do X, and in the end you didn't. OK fine, you didn't do it. There might be a hundred reasons why not, some of them interesting and others very prosaic. But the end result is what it is, and now you have a new configuration of circumstances facing you in the world. Next?

It seems clear to me that Schultz doesn't mean "failure" to be a reproach, either. The title poem (near the end of the book) describes his father's funeral. Somebody tells him, "Your father was always a nobody," and Schultz corrects him saying, "No, he wasn't a nobody, he was a failure." And then he goes on to describe his father, whom he plainly loved, and who was clearly a fine fellow with interesting and off-beat ideas for businesses that never worked.

The thing is that none of us ever hits 100% of what we set out to do, and that's OK. Sometimes we don't hit any of what we set out to do, either because it was out of our power to begin with, or because we went at it wrong, or because the world changed underneath us and made everything different. But it is still OK. Achieving the things you set out to do isn't really the point. At the end of the day -- at the end of our lives -- we won't be graded by how many items we have checked off of our To-Do lists, any more than we will be graded by how much money we have. Bumper stickers notwithstanding, the winner is not the one who dies with the most toys. The things that really matter are things along the way -- what kind of person I am, and you are; how we treat each other, and those close to us, and even those far away; what kind of balance we can keep our souls, and how much we love God. These kinds of things, and others beside them. They are what matter. But notice: if those are the things that matter, then one consequence has to be that Success as conventionally understood does not matter, or not so much. That is to say, Success understood as checking items off our To-Do lists, planning and setting and achieving goals -- all that manic, driven, targeted way of life -- is really not that important. It is at best what the Stoics called "an indifferent thing," neither good nor bad except in how we make use of it. (Just as a point of reference, they included money and food and health in the same category.) In fact, I might even venture to speculate that Success could turn out to be a distraction from (or a hazard to) our real job of leading the best life. And in that case, if Success is a hazard that can deflect us from leading the best life, then it is at least thinkable that Failure may not be so bad after all. I can imagine an updated St. Francis picturing Sister Failure as one of our guides along the way, in the same way that the real St. Francis spoke of Sister Poverty. Certainly in this place and time, here in today's America, any praise of Sister Failure would be about as deeply counter-cultural as it gets.

It is an odd thought. I think it came to me because for some time I have been thinking that the current chapter in my life is drawing to a close. Son 1 is out of the house, in boarding school. If Son 2 goes to a boarding school for high school, he'll be out of the house in another two years. And then Wife and I can sit down and dissolve the marriage without the boys caught in the crossfire. On this line of thought, I could find myself three years from today with no marriage and no house -- still bound to the boys, but otherwise freer and more mobile than I have been in ... well, longer than I can remember. And what will I do then? Honestly I don't know. But the autumnal sense of an approaching end has been growing in me for some time, and I see no sign of its going away. I get the same autumnal sense from Schultz's poems about failure. And I think this is why I felt the title call to me before I had ever laid my hands on the book.

It is an interesting place to be in, right now. I don't know where I will go next.
__________

Failure, by Philip Schultz

To pay for my father's funeral
I borrowed money from people
he already owed money to.
One called him a nobody.
No, I said, he was a failure.
You can't remember
a nobody's name, that's why
they're called nobodies.
Failures are unforgettable.
The rabbi who read a stock eulogy
about a man who didn't belong to
or believe in anything
was both a failure and a nobody.
He failed to imagine the son
and wife of the dead man
being shamed by each word.
To understand that not
believing in or belonging to
anything demanded a kind
of faith and buoyancy.
An uncle, counting on his fingers
my father's business failures —
a parking lot that raised geese,
a motel that raffled honeymoons,
a bowling alley with roving mariachis —
failed to love and honor his brother,
who showed him how to whistle
under covers, steal apples
with his right or left hand. Indeed,
my father was comical.
His watches pinched, he tripped
on his pant cuffs and snored
loudly in movies, where
his weariness overcame him
finally. He didn't believe in:
savings insurance newspapers
vegetables good or evil human
frailty history or God.
Our family avoided us,
fearing boils. I left town
but failed to get away.



Sunday, September 12, 2010

Sex at Dawn


Since when have brand-new books been published with websites already set up to advertise them? Have I missed something here?

I just bought a new book that I learned about via its website. It is called Sex at Dawn: The Prehistoric Origins of Modern Sexuality, by Christopher Ryan and Cacilda Jethá, and you can find its website here.

The thesis looks interesting -- that we evolved under conditions of casual promiscuity, and that therefore it is this (and not monogamy) which is natural to us. There is more, and I don't think they say that it would necessarily be all that easy to get back again. But I want to read the book before I critique it.

I think I have mentioned that I have a business trip coming up soon, and I am saving it for the airplane. I'll let you know what I think of it when I am done.




Saturday, September 11, 2010

Boarding school 3, Move-in

Saturday dawned. We got up, ate, and decided to get an early start. The schedule said we could start moving in at 10:00am, but that the Student Store opened at 9:00 for ordering uniforms. We decided to get there at 9:00. We arrived a little before, coming up the back way (as all new boarders were to do), and found a locked gate. Too soon? Maybe. About the time we decided to back our way down the access road, though, it swung open by itself. So we drove up, meandered a bit, and found a place to park. We figured our next stop was the Store, but no -- we met someone who told us we could go right on ahead and move Son 1 in. He signed in on a roster, got his room assignment and a key, and away we went.

The building where he lives was standing back when I attended Hogwarts (in the early Bronze Age), but it must have been refurbished. The light fixtures are all new, and there are ethernet ports in every room along with the electrical sockets. Fortunately Son 1 packed light. We unloaded the car, then I drove it down the hill to a longer-term parking space while the boys and Wife moved in all his stuff. When I got back, it was halfway done. Wife tried several times to put some of his stuff away for him, but I insisted that she let him do it so he'd know where everything was. Besides, there wasn't much.

In the process, we met briefly the dorm prefect, and also spent some time talking with the Senior in charge of the Orientation Group to which Son 1 was assigned. Turns out this latter fellow (named Chris) was also one of the football players, so he and Son 1 knew each other somewhat. They chatted about the football practices and about orientation, and then Chris said he had to go check up on some other kids but he'd be back.

Our next step was to walk down the hill towards the Student Store. When we got there, we found racks of jackets and slacks in different sizes. Here I really let Wife take over: there was no question of her going crazy with shopping, because the list of things to buy was absolutely specified and the only question was what size to order. It took her some time to coax Son 1 into a couple of different sizes of jacket and a couple different sizes of trousers before she could say definitely what size he needed, but then we just ordered the actual uniform online. There were parents there to help us, and laptops plugged in at a desk out in the open, all connected to the ordering site of the one company that provides the uniforms. Wife spent some time talking with one of the other mothers (I don't know about what, because I wandered in the other direction), and then we headed over to the dining hall for lunch.

Lunch was served buffet style, and for the most part was institutional "cheap and cheerful.: fried chicken, macaroni salad, bean salad, fresh fruit, and cookies. The four of us ate together, although Son 1 ate hardly anything. He said first that he wasn't hungry, and then that he didn't like fried chicken. (He did, however, make a bee-line for the table of cookies, once he saw it.) I couldn't help thinking, a little uncharitably, that the exact same reaction to one of my dinners would have inspired Wife to lecture me about how I was cruelly forcing the children into starvation by cooking food that "nobody would eat"; but when it was Hogwarts offering greasy, salty fried chicken she uttered not a peep. I know, that's a really petty and uncharitable thought. Sorry.

After lunch we split up. New students had to go to orientation activities on this lawn over here, while parents (and Son 2) went to welcoming speeches in the auditorium over there. We heard from the outgoing Head of School (who is being kept on in some public relations capacity), the incoming Head of School, the president of the PTA-equivalent organization, and the deans. They spoke on a variety of subjects. One talk was by the new Head of School, about how easy it is to keep in touch 24x7 these days, and why it is a bad idea. He urged us not to be the kind of parent who has to be obsessively in touch with our kids all the time. When he said that, Son 2 -- who was with us at the time -- turned and stared intently at Wife with deeply accusatory eyes. The other speakers all told us, in varying ways, what a fine choice we had made in sending our offspring to Hogwarts, and how well they were going to be nurtured and challenged and educated, and what amazing dedicated faculty there were here to work with them. I realize as I re-read this that I sound sarcastic, but I don't mean to. If you allow for the fact that reality is never as pretty as talk, nonetheless I am willing to believe that the things we were told are all fair enough. And even Wife -- for whom nothing is ever good enough -- said at the end that she was comfortable this school and these people were the right choice and would be good for Son 1.

We met briefly with Son 1's adviser -- mostly to get to know who he is. We were told we'd doubtless hear a lot from him in the weeks and months to come. He shook our hands, welcomed us, asked if we had any questions for him (at that point we didn't) ... and then introduced himself to the next boy's parents.

The next stop was the "New Parent Tea" over at the Admissions Office (which used to be the house of the school's founder). This was one of the events that had worried me a bit, lest Wife start button-holing someone and talking endlessly about ... well, whatever it might be. (The meeting with Son 1's adviser was another such occasion, and I was grateful it lasted so briefly.) But I needn't have worried. Wife got herself a glass of iced tea and a plate of hors d'oeuvres, and then sat down with Son 2 at an empty table. I mingled for a bit, chatting pleasantly with a number of new parents, and then joined them. And really, after about a half an hour or so, Wife and Son 2 were ready to leave. There was nothing more on the agenda, so that was fine with me. We took off -- not even seeing Son 1 to let him know we were going (but he was meanwhile following the new student agenda) -- and went back to my parents' house.

More irritation from my father because he had started dinner way too early, and so it was all done the minute we set foot inside. After our hors d'oeuvres, though, we really couldn't eat for a couple of hours. Not a tragedy in the grand scheme of things, but it contributed to his overall irritability that evening.

In fact, my father had been irritable ever since I got there the afternoon before. He was touchy and snappish, and seemed to start making his evening cocktails in the middle of the afternoon. So when he asked me for our Sunday schedule, I proposed getting the hell out of there as soon as possible so we could stop annoying him. This startled him. But then he explained that it had been a trying week. Partly my mother was -- is -- still recovering from a case of shingles, which meant that she had less energy and more pain than usual. Partly his whole sleep schedule had been seriously disoriented by getting up at 5:00 am every morning to drive Son 1 to football -- and especially ever since I explained to both him and Wife (Friday afternoon, as I described in that installment) that this venture had never been "necessary" he was pretty put out. Partly he found Son 1's constant levels of energy and motion -- all week long -- exhausting. And partly -- largely, I think -- he felt worn down by Wife's constant negativism. All week long, nothing had ever been right. Nothing was ever good enough. She complained about the food and about the school (Hogwarts? I guess) and about Son 1 and about me and about ... everything under the sun, apparently. No surprise really, because she does that all the time everywhere else, too. And it was just very, very draining, exhausting, irritating. One afternoon he had come back to the bedroom to find my mother lying on the bed in tears because it was all too much. Her pain was part of it, of course; and she had just gotten a panicked phone call from some client for whom the world was falling apart and who wanted her to fix it all. But also it had just been a very trying week. My dad said that if anything, he had been looking forward to the arrival of Son 2 and me because our respective cheerfulnesses would be a ray of light in all this gloom. And later that evening he actually apologized to everybody in the family for being so grumpy.

Saturday was another early night for all of us -- although it was a good bit quieter because of course Son 1 wasn't there. But we were still tired enough to turn in early.

Son 2 stayed with my folks Sunday morning, while Wife and I went back to Hogwarts. We had a couple things that Son 1 was missing, and there were some more talks. Most notable was a talk by a woman summarizing (or pitching) her book 7 Things Your Teenager Won't Tell You (and how to talk about them anyway). The gist of her talk was that many of the highly distinctive things people have noticed about how teenagers communicate are actually consequences of how their brains are developing ... this we have learned as we learn more about the biology if the brain in general. As a result, she went on, it's not very effective to expect teenagers to suddenly start acting and thinking exactly like we do, because in some cases they physically can't; so it actually works better to mold our expectations to what they can do, instead of demanding the reverse. What a concept.

It wasn't till after the talks that we connected with Son 1 for a few minutes -- long enough to take the extra items to his room, and then he was due elsewhere for another 15 minutes. After that we had lunch together -- sandwiches, as well as more bean salad, fruit, cookies -- and Son 1 took off. He explained he had more orientation events to get to. Actually he had a good half hour before the next event, but he was in a rush anyway. Wife insisted on a hug and got a halfway, one-arm hug. I shook his hand, and he vanished into a swirl of other kids. And that is the last we have seen of him up till now. He called briefly a couple days later (to ask me to mail him a book). He had a wonderful time on the Freshman Class backpacking trip, in the week before classes started. And he called last weekend (and spent most of his time talking with Son 2). Meanwhile it has been a lot quieter back home without him, and his cat spent a lot of time wandering around puzzled and meowing.

Friday, September 10, 2010

"You could visit D"

Next week I'll be out of town for a week and a half: first, for a two-day training class Over Here, and then for a week-long conference Over There. In between, I'm going to spend the weekend with D. She can't get away from work for more than that right now, but it does mean we'll see each other. In the background I kind of wonder what it will be like at home, with just Wife and Son 2 to be each other's company for so long. But I won't let the question keep me from going.

So last night I reminded Wife of this trip.

Wife: What trip?

Hosea: You remember -- I told you about it before.

Wife: You may have told me, but I don't remember. How long will you be gone?

Hosea: A week and a half.

Wife: Wow, that's pretty long.

Hosea: Yes, but I've wrapped together two different destinations: this training class Over Here, and then the conference Over There.

Wife: You're going to Over There? Gosh, that's right near the state where D lives. You could visit D.

What do I say? One day I'll just tell her that Yes, in fact, I am going to visit D. Heck, at some level she probably knows already, although I would bet a middling sum that she hasn't let herself know that she knows. But I haven't decided when to say something, and right now I am continuing to put it off. So I asked her, "Do you know where exactly in that state D lives?"

Wife: Ummm, ... no.

Hosea: Well I'm going to be in That City There, which is a fair distance from the state line, and I'll have to be at the conference every day. You aren't making this sound real practical.

Wife: [no real comment] ....

Wednesday, September 8, 2010

Boarding school 2, Football practice

The business of moving Son 1 onto campus -- I'll be frivolous and call the school "Hogwarts" -- actually began in early August.

Wife had been reading the materials that Hogwarts sent out to families of new students, and misunderstood them.  Somewhere in the middle of all this information she found a description of the athletic program.  The school offers three interscholastic sports in the fall (football and two others), plus a variety of other activities for students who aren't interested in any of those three.  Wife totally missed the second part, and jumped to the conclusion that each entering student was required to sign up for one of those three sports.  She telephoned the Director of Athletics to verify this, but he somehow failed to set her straight.  (I try to explain this below.)  All he told her was that football practice began the week before classes started.

Wife asked Son 1 which sport he wanted to play, and he decided that football was the one he disliked the least.  (His real athletic interests lie in other directions.)  So Wife became a woman-on-a-mission, possessed by the idea that Son 1 must join football practice the week before school started.  Now as it happens, my parents live very near Hogwarts.  Wife called them and arranged that Son 1 could stay there for the week while going to practice.  She then offered to come along, in order to drive him to and from practice.  (It's only about a twenty minute walk, but my suggestion that he walk it was hooted down by everybody involved.)  After much discussion -- way too much discussion -- the plan was settled.

Now, football practice was scheduled to take place twice a day: from 6:00 to 8:00 in the morning, and again from 4:00 to 6:00 in the afternoon.  That first installment meant getting Son 1 up no later than 5:15, so he could get there on time, and Wife is not very good these days about getting up early.  Here is how the first morning played out, as described later by my father:

"Like you, I seem to be able to wake up at a pre-set time. I woke up this morning at 5:05 am -- about ten minutes before my alarm was set to go off. I got up and started puttering about the kitchen, setting out the stuff Son 1 had requested for breakfast: peanut butter and jelly and bread to make a sandwich or two, along with milk and Ovaltine, and some coffee for Wife. At 5:15 I tiptoed into the living room and woke Son 1 just a second before his alarm beeped. He said he might have turned it off and gone back to sleep if I hadn't been there. As he ate breakfast I figured it would be quicker for me to get dressed and take him up to Hogwarts than wake up Wife. Good thing I did. The directions given me on the phone last week by the Athletic Director were incorrect. [Long time readers will recall that Wife panics when directions don't work out quite right, or when there is a chance of her getting lost.]  Driving in the main entrance led only to a locked gate. We had to go in the back way up a service road. We made every possible wrong turn before we finally arrived just a minute before 6:00 at the upper field where they have football and a running track. Son 1 had looked at a campus map earlier and, like you, was able to remember where things were and ended up being my guide as I drove up the mountain. The foot tour that he had taken during his summer visit also helped.

"When I went back to get him at 8:00 I took both Wife and your mom so that each would know how to get there in the future. When we found Son 1, he looked like he'd been in a battle: exhausted, sweat soaked, and covered with mud. He said he didn't realize how out of shape he had become. I just think he has never been in Football Shape. That is a whole different level of physical conditioning beyond anything else -- except, possibly, classical ballet! As soon as he got home he hit the shower and soaked in the tub to soothe sore muscles, and then ate ten sausages and six English muffins for a second breakfast. An hour or two later he boiled up two packages of Ramen noodles and ate them. He is now [mid-morning] sleeping on the living room sofa. Later some of us are taking him shopping for a pair of cleats and going to the grocery store for more food. He hasn't given us all that much detail of the workouts themselves, but to remark on the size of some of the seniors, and how far they can kick the ball. He clearly has a path marked out for himself as to where he has to go to succeed."

That night, I got a second installment from my father, describing the afternoon practice:
"Son 1 returned from his afternoon workout exhausted (again). This time they ended their workout in the weight room doing every kind of exercise designed to use muscles that their owners had never known they had. As soon as he walked in the door, he retired to a hot bath with three pints of Gatorade to restore his hydrolysis and electrolytes as he soaked his tired body. He finally emerged to eat a supper of spaghetti with my famous tomato sauce and a broiled sausage (only one) and then retired to the orange sofa where he is now asleep. (It's about 8:30 pm.) Wife, meanwhile fixed herself a couple of gin & tonics (half gin, half tonic) after she brought Son 1 back from Hogwarts, watched Jeopardy with your mom and me while Son 1 soaked, and zoned out after (almost during) a light supper (only half a sausage) at the same time as Son 1. Your mom and I are exiled to my study or hers so as not to disturb either of our guests. We might sit up and talk awhile, but I think I'd better get up at 5:05 once again just to make sure all goes as planned."

And so it went.  Occasionally I got phone calls filling me in on the details.  Tuesday's practice was worse than Monday's.  By Wednesday. Son 1 said that he thought he was getting his feet under him.  Then Thursday morning he hit a wall.  He came back from the morning practice, and couldn't go back.  He called me at work to tell me this, ... and, I think, to get my approval for dropping football.  I told him that it was too bad not to be able to finish the week; but if he couldn't, he couldn't.  I reminded him that all along he had had other options as well, so it wasn't going to be any big long-term tragedy if football didn't work out for him.  I insisted on only one thing: call the coach to let him know, before the time for afternoon practice to start -- don't just no-show.  Son 1 said he was fine with that.

So Son 1 and Wife had Thursday evening and Friday free.  I took Friday off of work, so that Son 2 and I could drive out there and meet up with the others.  We got a late start, because I had some odds and ends to tie up.  Then we had a long, hot drive through Friday traffic.  (The air conditioning in my car is out.) We finally got to town about 2:30 to find that my parents had held lunch for us (although I had called ahead to let them know we were going to be there well after lunchtime). When it turned out that neither Son 2 nor I was at all hungry, my father was rather put out. So the rest of them ate lunch.

After lunch, my father asked me to explain what I meant, when I said that Son 1 had always had lots of other options. I explained that it was very simple: there were three available interscholastic sports (football and the other two) but also lots of other after-school activities that one might pursue instead. The thing is that those other activities weren't specifically itemized in the printed materials, because they change from year to year and so nobody ever knows in advance what they are going to be. They can only be selected after school starts. But the printed material is very clear that they exist if only you read it attentively.

What appears to have happened, I told him, is that Wife wanted to make damned sure that every possible variable related to Son 1's school year was defined and nailed down unmoveably before school started … probably because she is so terrified of any indeterminacy or uncertainty. So her eyes must have glossed over the part about the other activities, because they weren't so clear-cut. Yes, she telephoned the Athletic Director, and came away with her (mis-)understanding confirmed that Son 1 had to choose one of the three interscholastic sports. I have no idea how this happened, except that she frequently misunderstands what people tell her. To be charitable, I invented a Just-So-Story that the Athletic Director must have assumed she was restricting her questions to the interscholastic program from the outset, because naturally he would have assumed that she had read the printed material on the website and therefore already knew that he couldn't speak to the other activities until after school started.

Why does all this matter? Well, it really doesn't except that my father started to get riled and say (with Wife in the room) "Do you mean that all this getting up at 5:00 in the morning was totally unnecessary and just came from misreading the damned catalog??" I interposed at this point a suggestion that it wasn't really a tragedy. I explained that I had tried to tell both Son 1 and Wife at the time that there were, after all, other choices: this part is true, although my voice was small in that conversation and Wife's was large (amplified by the righteous self-confidence that stemmed from her having just now gotten off the phone with the Athletic Director). Anyway, when I pointed this out Son 1 had said, "No, it's OK, I think I want to give football a try." Maybe he meant it. Maybe he meant he wanted to humor Wife. I have no idea. In any event, I let it drop; and what I told my father and Wife on Friday afternoon was that I figured if Son 1 wanted to try out football, then we should let him. Now that he had tried it and concluded it wasn't for him, he could go do something else. I hoped that this would add up to a certain amount of oil on the waters.

The boys spent all Friday afternoon splashing in my parents' pool in the most vigorous possible way … a few times it looked like it narrowly avoided outright violence, but never quite made it. Somehow they got into a water balloon fight with the people next door.  There was a bit of joking about how they must have missed each other, although they both denied it. (But later, Son 2 admitted that he did miss having Son 1 to talk to as they both fell asleep at night.)  I stayed away from most conversation. My father had planned a huge dinner, but nobody was all that interested so we had bits and bobs instead, left over from lunch.  And we all went to bed early.

Tuesday, September 7, 2010

How do you handle money?

At one point, on our last date, D asked me if I could help her with the cost of her airline ticket. I understand why she asked -- most of my expenses were being picked up by my company, so the financial impact of the date fell disproportionately on her. And from time to time she has mentioned that if we are going to be involved in the long term we have to be able at least to discuss money rationally.

I didn't react too well at the time, however. Instead of being able to discuss it calmly, I sank into a depression that lasted much of the evening. Recently as we were talking on the phone, she tried to ask why I reacted so badly, and again the conversation didn't get very far. But it left me wondering about myself, and in a while I was able to see at least parts of an answer.

The first point, and the most basic one, is that I am not at all consistent in how I feel about money. Anybody (like D) who tries to deduce my underlying attitudes about money by watching my behavior will end up very confused, ... because the behavior is confused. It is not, as I say, consistent. I can fret and agonize over small sums, and then write out large sums without blinking. It makes no sense.

Or rather, the sense it makes is a kind of complex emotional sense, and I am not sure that I can identify all the pieces. One piece is that I don't grok money terribly well, and so I don't enjoy thinking about it. I'll do it as a chore, because I have to; and Heaven knows I'm better at it than Wife. But the very fact that it takes me so long each weekend to make myself sit down and do the bills -- and that after all that angst and delay I'll only do what is absolutely necessary, postponing the rest -- is a sign to myself that I would rather do ... if not "almost anything," then certainly many other things. So there is a measure of discomfort there, from the get-go.

Because I don't grok money very well, I rely heavily on constructing for myself some kind of frame-story when I am dealing with a financial situation, and these frame stories allow me to see the situation as a picture, where the decisions I have to make become obvious. So when Wife spends a handful of change on a spool of thread in a color she's already got, I see it as part of a frame-story about hoarding and greed and compulsive acquisition and waste. Those are all very ugly things, and I react by hitting the roof. If I then have to turn around the very same day and write out an installment on Son 1's tuition at his new high school -- a sum which, by year's end, will have added up to something in the neighborhood of ten thousand times more than the spool of thread (just for the sake of round numbers) -- I see it as part of a frame-story about prioritizing my children's education, and I'm very calm about it all.

What is more, it can sometimes be difficult for me to shift gears, to re-frame the same event in a different story. Or say rather, that I can do it but I don't find it easy to do on the spot, on the fly. So when I am travelling on the company's dime, for example, the narrative that is running through my head is a narrative about, "How am I going to account for myself to the mysterious trolls in Corporate Accounting?" And part of my thought is that I am given a lot of leeway precisely because I have never run afoul of the system. My fear is that if I ever do slip up, I will invite a lot more scrutiny in the future ... and I'd rather avoid the extra scrutiny. So any time D and I go somewhere in the context of one of my business trips, I hear a little voice in the back of my head murmuring this narrative over and over. It makes me fretful trying to parcel out expenses into the two buckets, Corporate and Personal (totally regardless of how much money -- or how little -- we are really talking about). And so it can be a lot harder than you would think for me to stop that Corporate-oriented monologue long enough to break in with a simple question like, "Is this expense here really all that important in the big picture? Isn't that expense there really remarkably cheap if it spells the difference between being able to see D and not?" These are obvious logical questions, and anybody who felt comfortable with the topic of money would ask them as a matter of course. But because of where I find myself with relation to the topic, it can be awkward to get from here to there.

So far as I can reconstruct it, what happened that night during our last date is that we were driving out to dinner somewhere, which means that the Corporate Accounting narrative was already nagging endlessly in the back of my head. Then en route D asked the question about her plane tickets. I think what happened inside my head was that somehow this threw me -- without even stepping on the clutch to shift gears -- into an entirely different frame-story whose message is, "Hosea, you're a cheapskate (or you would have volunteered to help with her tickets without waiting for her to say something)." I don't say that's what she was trying to achieve, but that's how I remember it from the inside. And so I was rattled: partly from the sudden change of narrative; partly because the new narrative concerned a bill (her airfare) that was probably going to be ten times anything we could possibly spend on dinner that night, and I was already fretting about dinner (because of the whole Corporate-accounting mantra); and partly because I would do almost anything to avoid being thought a cheapskate. Emotionally, I was being pulled hard in two flatly opposite directions; intellectually, I was trying to see the situation through two incompatible sets of lenses. And I shut down.

Great, now what? Well, in the aftermath of our somewhat unconstructive phone call, I sent her a check for some fraction of the tickets. At that point, because the conversation had been so difficult, she actually felt funnier about accepting it than I did about writing it. But I think this business of competing frame stories explains my side, at least. Really, none of my reactions had anything to do with the amount of money in question. But time and distance allowed me to shift my internal frame story. And once I had done that, the thing was much easier.

I don't know if there is any kind of advice here for the future ....