Sometime while I was staying with the Schmidts last month, I started thinking about the trope of the "childless cat lady." Of course the phrase got a lot of attention during the last election, because the news media pointed out that some years earlier (before he was a candidate for anything, let alone an officeholder), JD Vance had used it in an interview with Fox News. So in a sense cat ladies had their moment in the sun last year, just as "bad hombres" did eight years earlier.
But what, I began to wonder, really is the distinguishing characteristic of a childless cat lady, and why do they get so much grief?
Why do people look down on childless cat ladies?
I tried googling this question, and all I found were articles saying that childless cat ladies aren't nearly as bad as everyone thinks. Here's a collection of them:
- The Guardian, "Claws out! Why pop culture clings to the crazy cat lady," April 16, 2018
- NBC News, "JD Vance doubles down on 'childless cat ladies' dig: 'I've got nothing against cats'," July 26, 2024
- City Journal, "About Those 'Childless Cat Ladies'," September 3, 2024
- Ipsos, "Why America's childless cat ladies are more than just Taylor Swift," September 11, 2024
- The Cutprice Guignol, "On Childless Cat Ladies," September 16, 2024
- The Conversation, "‘Childless cat ladies’ have long contributed to the welfare of American children − and the nation," October 21, 2024
- The Guardian, "Fur and loathing: do America’s ‘childless cat ladies’ hold the key to the US election?" November 3, 2024
And that's great to know—don't get me wrong. I guess it's reassuring to hear that the stereotype is incorrect. But I wanted historical information on where the stereotype came from in the first place—and, more particularly, on what the image means in the popular psyche. A couple of articles waved vaguely towards the idea that the condemnation of childless cat ladies was a holdover from the ancient fear of witches. But that doesn't sound likely to me.



